The mainstream press barely bothered to give a nod to what has come to be a mind-numbing ritual of bait, switch and dodge.
The alternative press knew better than to look to the assembled ministers in Doha for any real news, focusing instead on the grim report released early last week by the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research and Climate Analytics.
The 84-page report, titled “Turn Down the Heat” and funded by that radical fringe group known as the World Bank, demonstrates that if we continue our reckless heating of the planet at the present rate, all the scenarios of which readers of this blog are well aware—sea level rise, droughts and floods leading to severe food shortages, more frequent and more severe storms, loss of biodiversity and loss of human life on a biblical scale—will come to pass.
The executive summary of the report concludes with a measure of urgency:
“A 4C world is likely to be in which communities, cities and countries would experience severe disruptions, damage and dislocation, with many of these risks spread unequally. It is likely that the poor will suffer most and the global community could become more fractured and unequal than today. The projected 4C warming simply must not be allowed to occur–the heat must be turned down. Only early, cooperative, international actions can make that happen.”
But this takes us in circular fashion back to Doha, where as we know, nothing substantive is going on.
Those of us who are aware of what’s happening on the climate front—and let’s face it, there aren’t that many of us, we probably form our own little 1% club—find it frustrating and frightening to have to sit by and watch as our beloved planet goes into drastic human-induced traumatic shock while our leaders bicker and fiddle and run down the clock.
I find myself constantly pulled between A) wanting to support political efforts like Bill McKibben’s “Do the Math” tour, which aims to educate and inspire action (specifically, divestment from fossil fuel companies to pressure them to reinvent themselves as bonafide green energy companies) and B) wanting to simply hunker down and build resilience at the local level, perhaps enrolling myself and my sons in a crash course in how to survive a disaster.
For the moment, I am focusing on doing what I can within my purview as a teacher to help the upcoming generation of young adults get a handle on what’s happening to our climate, and do their own productive thinking about how to engage in the struggle to turn things around.
Yesterday I was fortunate to have had a chance to participate in a small way in my colleague Eban Goodstein’s C2C Fellows Workshop, a national program based at Bard College that seeks to give young people the skills and understanding to become successful leaders in the global effort to stabilize our climate and create a sustainable economy.
This is an ambitious undertaking, and Goodstein is going at it full tilt, holding weekend workshops several times a year at college campuses across the country, and bringing graduate students to Bard, with generous funding, to undertake Master’s degree programs in environmental policy with a special emphasis on climate-related policy and advocacy.
As Goodstein puts it, “Stabilizing the climate is not the work of a year, of a presidential term, or of a decade. It is the work of a generation.”
I see it as an essential commitment and responsibility to use my skills as a writer, scholar and teacher to help equip the upcoming generation for this great work we must all undertake now.
Goodstein is a unique blend of science policy wonk and communications guru, and I’m convinced that it’s at this very nexus that real change on the climate front will be forged.
All the dire scientific reports in the world won’t get people to wake up and change their daily habits, or insist that policy changes are made at the local, state, national and international levels, if the information is not presented in clear, compelling language.
A significant portion of the C2C Workshop, therefore, is spent in developing students’ storytelling skills.
It was interesting, and somewhat disheartening, to watch the students’ puzzled reaction when asked by Goodstein to talk about a favorite storyteller in their family. Very few hands went up.
This is because most Americans today are reared listening to the TV tell us stories, not cherished individuals in our actual lives. We are avid but passive consumers of prepackaged stories, and as a result most of us—unless we have the ambition to become stand-up comedians—don’t see storytelling as a skill we need to master.
Goodstein’s important insight is that storytelling is key to getting people’s attention, and telling a good story is essential to success in environmental advocacy and politics.
Good persuasive communication, he said, starts with a personal story, and then moves into the political. Hook your audience with a personal anecdote, keep their attention with a strong narrative, and then finish up with a call to action. And once you’ve got a strong story developed, practice telling it, over and over again, until you can do it in your sleep.
Armed with this advice, the group of some 80 students broke into smaller groups of five, each accompanied by a faculty or graduate student facilitator, for a two-hour intensive storytelling workshop. Our task was to each come up with a short story about an inspiring person or event, write it up and tell it three times, to three different partners, then refine it and tell it again to the whole group.
The stories would be refined further the next day, told again to new audiences, and several would be singled out for telling to the entire big group, and given awards.
This is the kind of work for which I have been preparing my whole life. There is nothing I would rather do than facilitate a writing workshop on inspiring stories! And it gives me special joy to do it as part of a program aimed at giving young people the skills and mojo to tell the climate change story in a way that galvanizes action.
It may be that in the end, I would have been better served by spending my time learning survival tactics in the woods, but the truth is that even in the most dire circumstances, human beings have always needed their storytellers. A good story well told can keep us warm in ways that may not be measurable, but that are profound nevertheless.
Here is the story that I wrote and told the students yesterday in our workshop. I offered it to them—and now to you—with love and an earnest desire that it may inspire us all to each get to work on the climate change issue—in our own ways and spheres—before it’s too late.
My friend Pauline tells the story of how she came home from work one day and discovered that a civil war had started in her country, Congo-Brazzaville. Suddenly she had ten people, mostly women and children, sheltering in her house as gunfire and bombs shook the streets of the city.
When a bomb hit the house, she and her family and friends knew they needed to make a run for it. They gathered what food and supplies they could carry, and left the house in the middle of the night, heading for the countryside.
What followed was weeks of deprivation and terror as they huddled in the forest waiting for the conflict to die down so that it would be safe to return home.
I tell this story because it is emblematic of the many stories I have studied over the years, in which women and children are disproportionately affected as victims of social conflict and war.
I tell it because I fear that in the age of climate change this is a story that will be repeated over and over again. Whether the violence is human—men with guns—or natural—hurricanes or droughts—the effects will be the same: women and children on the run, vulnerable and afraid.
Recent studies indicate that hundreds of millions of people will become climate refugees in the next half-century. And they won’t all be in Bangladesh or the Maldives, either. Just ask a former resident of Breezy Point in New York City, devastated by Hurricane Sandy, how it feels.
In our lifetimes we will all witness–and many of us will likely experience—the kind of fear and hardship that Pauline lived through, when the social order disintegrated and violence became the norm.
There are many, many guns in America. It would not take much in the way of food and energy shortages to trigger violence.
Sometimes I find myself wondering whether I should be learning and then teaching others survival skills, instead of critical thinking and writing.
What good will my PhD in literature do me in an age of relentless, recurring Hurricane Sandys? What good will a vaunted college degree do my students?
But I do continue to believe that the stories of survivors like Pauline matter, and increasingly these are the stories I offer students in my classes on human rights, environmental justice, politics and literature.
We all need to learn from Pauline and other survivors about the amazing resilience of the human spirit. Even in the face of terror and chaos, people can choose to be compassionate, generous and respectful of one another. We don’t all choose the violent path.
It will not help any of us to focus on fear right now, as the climate change crisis gains momentum and threatens to engulf us. What we must concentrate on instead is hope, resilience and solidarity. That’s what the world needs from us now.